What OCD Really Looks Like: Understanding Treatment, Subtypes & How to Do No Harm as a Therapist
When most of us learned about OCD in grad school, it probably looked like excessive hand-washing or checking the stove over and over. But in the therapy room, what OCD actually looks like can be confusing, alarming, and easy to miss—especially if you aren’t trained in recognizing its many subtypes.
In this episode of Not Boring CEs, I sat down with Beth Brawley, LPC, founder of Life Without Anxiety and a specialist in OCD treatment. We covered everything from what makes a thought “ego-dystonic” to how to treat even the most distressing fears without doing harm. Whether you’re a new clinician, a seasoned therapist, or someone who’s been hesitant to explore ERP, this one’s for you.
What Is OCD, Really?
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD) is not just about being “neat” or “a little anxious.” Beth breaks it down simply:
- Obsessions are unwanted, intrusive thoughts, images, or urges that feel distressing and out of character.
- Compulsions (also called rituals or safety behaviors) are the things people do to try to get rid of that distress.
OCD operates on a negative reinforcement loop: the more a person engages in compulsions, the more their brain believes those actions are necessary for safety. Relief becomes short-lived, and the anxiety cycle grows stronger.
Beth explains it like a snowball rolling downhill—it may start small, but by the time it gets to your office, it’s massive.
Intrusive Thoughts Are Human. OCD Makes Them Stick.
Here’s the thing: all of us have intrusive thoughts. Ever stood on a rooftop and thought, “What if I jumped?” That’s normal.
But in someone with OCD, that same thought becomes sticky. It’s not just a passing “whoa” moment—it’s evidence that something is wrong. The brain turns it into a crisis. That’s when intrusive thoughts go from quirky to clinically significant.
Subtypes: It’s All Ice Cream (Just Different Flavors)
Beth’s go-to analogy? OCD subtypes are like the 31 flavors at Baskin Robbins. They all fall under the OCD umbrella, but they show up in wildly different ways. Examples include:
- Contamination OCD: Fear of germs, illness, or spreading harm.
- Harm OCD: Fear of hurting others or oneself (e.g., “What if I stab my partner while chopping veggies?”).
- Scrupulosity: Obsessive fears about morality or religious wrongdoing.
- Sexuality/Orientation OCD: Doubts around sexual identity or arousal.
- Existential OCD: Obsessive worry about the meaning of life, death, or consciousness.
Every subtype is treated the same way—through Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP)—but they can present very differently, and that’s where awareness matters most.
Why Subtype Awareness Matters (A Lot)
Beth shared a powerful warning: if a therapist doesn’t recognize harm or sexual obsessions as OCD, they may mistakenly report a client or misunderstand the clinical issue. This can be traumatizing for the client and dysregulating for the therapist.
The key clinical question? Is the thought ego-dystonic?
If a client is deeply distressed by a thought and desperate to stop it, that’s a sign it’s OCD—not a genuine risk.
Evidence-Based Treatment: What ERP Really Looks Like
Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) is the gold standard treatment for OCD. Here’s what it involves:
- Exposure: Facing the feared thought, image, or situation (e.g., touching a “dirty” doorknob).
- Response Prevention: Resisting the compulsion (e.g., not washing hands after the doorknob).
Beth emphasizes that clients are already being exposed in everyday life. The real work is helping them resist compulsions and tolerate distress—without avoidance or rituals.
She uses SUDS (subjective units of distress) ratings and sometimes tosses hierarchy out the window, letting clients draw “exposures” from a grab bag to mimic the randomness of real life.
ERP for “Untestable” Fears
What about fears you can’t test, like pedophilia OCD or existential dread? ERP still works—just differently.
Beth helps clients design exposures rooted in their values. For example, a new parent with harm-related fears might practice holding and rocking their baby, even while feeling anxiety. The goal is not to prove the fear wrong, but to live life despite the fear.
Avoiding the Landmines
Beth shared common mistakes therapists can make when working with clients who have OCD, even without realizing it:
- Giving reassurance (“You’d never do that, you’re a good person!”)
- Using logic to battle intrusive thoughts (“That doesn’t make sense, so it can’t be real.”)
- Unintentionally becoming part of the compulsion loop (e.g., always assigning exposures, acting as a safety cue)
Instead, Beth encourages clinicians to stay grounded in ERP principles, avoid moralizing thoughts, and help clients build their own internal coping tools.
ERP ≠ Cruel Exposure
Let’s bust a myth: ERP isn’t about torture.
Ethical ERP is based on acceptable risk, never gratuitous distress. Therapists are partners in the process—not villains forcing people to do terrifying things. Beth says it best: “Anxiety is a safe, universal experience. We’re not avoiding it—we’re teaching clients they can handle it.”
OCD vs. OCPD vs. Perinatal Anxiety
The episode also dives into how to:
- Differentiate OCD from OCPD (which is often ego-syntonic and less distressing)
- Understand perinatal OCD and why it affects both birthing and non-birthing parents
- Know when to refer out, especially when you don’t feel competent treating OCD
Beth also emphasized that medication can be helpful—but it’s not the treatment itself. It’s a support tool that can make ERP more accessible.
Want to Support Someone with OCD?
Partners and parents are often unintentionally part of the problem. Through love, they accommodate, rescue, or push too hard. Beth advocates for psychoeducation and involvement—especially helping loved ones learn how to support without reinforcing compulsions.
Final Thoughts: Fail, Learn, Repeat
Beth’s message is one of empowerment. She reminds us that failure is not a moral issue—it’s just data. That willingness to “fail fast” (as entrepreneurs say) can also apply to therapy: if we don’t tolerate failure, we can’t grow. That’s as true for therapists as it is for clients.
Want more trainings that don’t suck?
This episode is part of Not Boring CEs, where you can knock out your required CEs for therapists with real conversations—not dry PowerPoints.
You can get all your online education courses in one fun, engaging place at NotBoringCEs.com. Because continuing education for counselors shouldn’t make you question your life choices.
One Comment